Author    |    Excerpts    |     Reviews   |    Comments     |    Articles    |    Pitch    |    Purchase    |     Home   

Order a signed copy of The Lost Moonflower now by clicking here !   

   
   
  Courting controversy: Former St. John priest's new novel not for sale in church's bookstore
By Diane Reynolds, Times Staff Writer
 
   
  In his novel The Lost Moonflower, the Rev. Isaac Karoor recreates the first century Roman world and depicts Biblical women as deacons in the early church.

His goals are twofold. He hopes his book will enhance women's dignity within the Catholic Church, and, by bringing Biblical characters to life, encourage people to read the Bible.

 
   
 

Karoor, who served as a priest at St. John Roman Catholic Church in Westminster for seven years in the 1990s, said the idea for his novel was born while he was working at St. John.

But the book, released by Tate Publishing, a Protestant publisher, is not for sale at the St. John bookstore.  

"It's an area I didn't want to get into," said former St. John administrator, the Rev. Kevin Mueller, who backed the bookstore's decision not to carry the novel.

While the novel may be theologically sound, he said, the bookstore, which is small, focuses on mainstream works such as catechisms that are fully endorsed by the Roman Catholic Church.  

"They want to sell nothing that would cause a controversy," he said.

Karoor, who now serves as priest at St. Ignatius Roman Catholic Church in Hickory, just north of Belair, hopes St. John's new administrator, the Rev. Patrick Carrion, will allow the bookstore to sell the novel.


        Karoor with The Lost Moonflower

 
 

Many of his old parishioners are interested in it, he said.

The book, Karoor noted, was reviewed in the July 20 Catholic Review.

Carrion said he has not received a copy and can not yet form an opinion of its merits, but he said there are many books the St. John store does not carry.

Belief in women

The novel was the culmination of Karoor's years of observing women in subordinate roles. 

As a child growing up in India, he saw his mother walk three paces behind his father. He heard both his grandfather and father use passages from the Bible to put down women.  

He found that wrong.

He has seen his sister become a lawyer and his nieces treated as equals. But the Catholic Church, he contends, still won't grant women the equality they deserve.

The book argues that women should be ordained as deacons, an idea being studied by the Catholic Church, he said.

The lost moonflower of the book's title is Phoebe, a woman mentioned in the Bible in Paul's letter to the Romans.  

In the novel, both Peter and Paul endorse Phoebe, a strong, educated woman, as a leader in the church.  

She and Luke, author of the gospel of Luke, fall in love, but she chooses the path of celibacy.

The novel shows what struggle celibacy can be, Karoor said.  "If they think it is romantic, they haven't lived it," he said.

A labor of love

For five years, Karoor spent his spare time on the novel, researching it with a friend, Marian Carr, now deceased.

He wanted to bring the first century world alive for readers, conveying the sights, sounds and smells of the ancient Roman Empire.  

He wanted the characters, taken from the Bible, to be living, full-bodied people.

He and Carr traveled to cities mentioned in the Bible, including Corinth, Rome and Jerusalem. They even grew a moonflower, a symbol of how women's early flourishing as church leaders has closed up as the moonflower closes up at night.

And Karoor took at least five creative writing classes at Johns Hopkins University to polish his manuscript.

Carr edited the book, double-checking every fact.

Karoor was told by publishers to cut the book's length, so he did.  

"It was like doing surgery on your own child," he said.

When Tate Publishing, a small press in Mustang, Okla., picked up his novel, he had to sign a statement agreeing that the Bible is the word of God.

An audio version of the book will be released soon, he said, with a male voice reading the parts from Luke's perspective and a female voice reading from Phoebe's perspective.

Traditional and progressive

"I'm a traditional pastor but a progressive theologian," Karoor said.  

Theologians are the church's visionaries, he said, pushing the church towards the future, while pastors should uphold the present interpretation of scripture.

He doesn't preach in favor of women deacons from the pulpit, he said.  

What he does in his official capacity is organize Bible studies, an activity encouraged by Vatican II.  

"Ignorance of Scripture is ignorance of Christ," he said, quoting St. Jerome. "Without Scripture, we are nowhere."

At St. John, about 200 attended his Bible study, he said.  

"The people at St. John loved him a lot," said his friend, Jack Carr, widower of Marian Carr and a parishioner at the church.

Reach staff writer Diane Reynolds at 410-857-7873 or reynoldsd@lcniofmd.com

 
   
 

Article from the August 13, 2006 paper edition of Carroll County Times

© 2007   The Lost Moonflower, Isaac Karoor